Re-Watch Review: The Summer I Turned Pretty S1-EP5

Episode synopsis

S1 EP5 – Summer Catch: Believing that Conrad might act on his feelings for her, Belly makes a decision. But when Belly and Conrad finally get a chance to talk, things don’t go as she expected, and she wonders if she’s had her eye on the wrong Fisher brother. Steven is assigned to work the poker room at the country club, and Laurel and Susannah have a night out.

Cast 

Lola Tung…Belly

Jackie Chung…Laurel

Rachel Blanchard…Susannah

Christopher Briney…Conrad

Gavin Casalegno…Jeremiah

Sean Kaufman…Steven

Alfredo Narciso…Cleveland

Minnie Mills…Shayla

David Iacono…Cam

Best character

I want to pick Conrad because he’s adorable in this episode and it’s so nice to see him happy, but mostly because of the little boop he gives Junior Mint. It’s so freaking cute, Christopher Briney is very charming. 

Here is the boop for you all to enjoy – it’s 11 seconds in:

Best supporting character 

Ah Cam Cameron you sweet summer child. He’s so nice in this episode, but he is quite lame, isn’t he? Avocado and sprout sandwiches? C’mon dude. It was pretty cute when he saw the whale though. 

Also, he took his ‘break up’ with Belly very well. He handled it like an adult and didn’t make a huge scene about it, I can respect that.

Favourite scenes

*I do not own the rights to any videos in this post, no copyright infringement was intended. All rights go to the production studio*

I think this is my favourite opening of the whole show. How Belly never realised Conrad likes her is beyond me. He did not hesitate to volunteer to dance with her and the way he smiles and laughs with her. Adorable.

What a cutie. You know he’s down bad when the first thing he does when he wakes up is smile.

Best quotes and one liners

SHAYLA: The first time I got drunk, I FaceTimed each one of my exes, one by one, and made them tell me why we broke up.


SHAYLA: Does Jere ever take anything seriously? 

STEVEN: Yeah, food and flirting.


DARA: Your girl Belly’s a disaster in heels. 

JEREMIAH: You know what? Belly’s actually a good dancer. The waltz is just dumb.


CAM: Carpe diem, Flavia. You should be with the person you really want to be with And I hope he treats you right.


BELLY: Jeremiah, please save me! My mom wants to braid my hair!


BELLY: Susannah told me that when I was born, she knew I was destined for one of her boys. I always hoped it would be Conrad. But here I am, about to kiss Jeremiah Fisher.

Best musical moment

Laurel and Susannah dancing to Don’t Cha by Pussy Cat Dolls is absolutely iconic. I was hoping to find a clip of it, but couldn’t unfortunately.

Final thoughts and fun facts

I’m really not a fan of Belly and Jeremiah together, maybe if I didn’t know what he did in the books I wouldn’t dislike him so much. But I am a Conrad girlie through and through. Plus I find Chris more attractive, sorry Gavin. 

Susannah wanting to paint Jeremiah as Hermes is actually very profound, is that the right word? I don’t think it is but I say this because Jeremiah is mischievous just like Hermes and it’s a very subtle hint, but it really means something. Well, I’m assuming they did it for this reason, if not, a happy accident. 


Check out Young Creative Press on all socials

You can also check out my StoryGraph here

Like this post? Why not read this one too: Mid-Year Wrap-Up: 2023 Reading Goals Update

Leave a Reply